Council of State Neurosurgical Societies meeting, October 15-16, 2010
Attendance: 45 delegates from state
societies, 12 delegates appointed by the AANS and 17 delegates appointed by the
CNS and all 13 resident fellows.
Meeting Highlights:
1. The neurosurgical practice management organization
(NERVES) noted a membership of 310 practices encompassing 440 neurosurgeons and
220 non-doc providers. The practices were 69% private, 26% academic and 5%
hospital based. Their average neurosurgeon turns out over 11,000 RVU’s a year,
takes home around 650K, gets 53% of revenue from FFS, 23% from Medicare, 8%
from Work Comp and 6% from Medicaid and gets 2K/24 hours from trauma/ED
coverage.
2. Of the 5000 or so community hospitals in America, 1673 are trauma centers with 203 Level I and 271 Level II. About half the level I
& II centers are ACS certified (the rest are locally declared) and most of
the 1,100 or so Level III-V centers are self designated.
3. Historically, about one-half of the eligible state
society delegates and the appointed AANS/CNS delegates show up at the CSNS
meeting. The 13 resident fellows have an 80% attendance rate.
4. The official position of the AANS/CNS Washington
Committee is to work toward changing or repealing the Obamacare Independent
Payment Advisory Board, the penalties for not participating in PQRI and the
public reporting of doc performance date unless the criteria are transparent
and approved by neurosurgery. They will push for a national EMS/Trauma system
and killing the SGR as well as promoting private contracting between doc and
medicare patient (without requiring the doc to quit Medicare altogether) and,
of course, liability reform.
5. The Neurosurgical Political Action Committee has raised
about 450K this election cycle from the usual 9% of America’s neurosurgeons and
needs another 50 K for November.
6. Rusty Rodts, President of the CNS, pointed out the new
annual meeting scheduling designed to improve the attendee’s experience. He
highlighted the commencement of first meeting session on Sunday afternoon
before the opening reception, the termination of each day’s agenda earlier in
the afternoon leaving a little more time for attendee fun and evening dinner
seminars (which were sold out for this meeting). He also indicated a
realignment of the Congress’s support for political endeavors in light of its
501(c)3 charter which, as a purely educational organization, severely limits
support of political items (such as the AANS/CNS Washington Committee—the AANS
has no such limitations since it is a 501(c)6 trade association).
7. Saw Jim Bean, M.D., from Lexington, Kentucky, receive
the Leibrock Lifetime Achievement Award for his many outstanding contributions
to national neurosurgery including stints as CSNS Chairman and AANS President.
8. A report was given pursuant to a previous resolution
that noted there are currently 109 specialty hospitals in the USA, up from 92 in 2003 and 29 in 1990. Most of them are for cardiology or general
orthopedics with only 31 dedicated to spine. It appears that none of the 31
are owned solely by neurosurgeons but all have neurosurgeons on staff with
staff ownership varying from 2-10% per doc.
The assembled CSNS delegates took the following actions on
the submitted resolutions.
RESOLUTION I-2010F—
Adopted
Title:
CSNS Meeting Timing and the Delegate
BE IT RESOLVED, that the Membership/State Societies Committee conduct
a survey of CSNS delegates to obtain preferences regarding meeting length and
schedule and to report survey results at the spring 2011 CSNS meeting.
RESOLUTION II-2010F—Not adopted
Title: Comparing
Decompression in Degenerative Lumbar Stenosis With and Without Fusion
BE IT RESOLVED, the CNS and AANS promote the establishment of a
clinical study which answers the question "In the surgical treatment of
degenerative lumbar stenosis without a spondylolithesis, deformity or
preexisting instability, what patient criteria should be present to suggest
that a lumbar decompression with arthrodesis would be superior to a
decompression alone in producing the best patient outcome?"
RESOLUTION
III-2010F—Adopted (and combined with Resolution VIII)
Title: Neurosurgery Patient Registries
BE IT RESOLVED,
that the CSNS advocate for the immediate creation of
a joint committee with the AANS and the CNS for evaluating and optimizing
health information technology with said committee reporting to the CSNS on a
semi-annual basis and that CSNS develop and educational program regarding the
above to be presented at the spring 2011 CSNS meeting.
RESOLUTION
IV-2010F—Adopted
Title: CSNS Support for Intraoperative Neurophysiologic
Monitoring
BE IT RESOLVED,
that the CSNS create a resource document that explores
the indications and implications of Intraoperative Neurophysiologic Monitoring
including CMD regulations, health insurer policies for reimbursement,
medico-legal ramifications and established clinical utility.
RESOLUTION V-2010F--Adopted
Title: Exploring the format, duration, and standardization
of hand-offs across neurosurgical residencies
BE IT RESOLVED, that the CSNS study and report on the elements
necessary for optimal hand-offs between neurosurgeons.
RESOLUTION VI-2010F—Not Adopted
Title:Advocacy for Healthcare Reform
BE IT RESOLVED, that the CSNS
request the Washington Committee change its focus of advocacy in the area of
healthcare system reform to support for a single-payer healthcare system for
the USA.
RESOLUTION VII-2010F—Adopted
Title: CSNS Website Link to the Online Emergency
Department Neurosurgery Coverage Regionalization Project
BE IT RESOLVED, that the CSNS create a link (for members only) on
its current homepage (cnsonline.org) to provide online access to the Emergency
Department Neurosurgery Coverage Regionalization Project.
RESOLUTION IX-2010F—Adopted
Title: Fraudulent Disclosure
BE IT RESOLVED, that the CSNS request the AANS/CNS more clearly
define their policy regarding conflict of interest disclosures and the
ramifications of failure to disclose in presentations and publications, and
that such policies meet or exceed the standards of other similar organizations. |